MCH INS Depreciated Labor Costs


On Jul. 3, MCH INS issued bulletin on non-tangible item depreciation.


  • MCH INS issued Bulletin 2024-18-INS in regard to depreciation of non-tangible items.
  • Prohibits insurers from depreciating labor costs when paying a homeowners claim.
  • Unless the insured has agreed in advance to reduction in exchange for lower premium.
  • Actual Cash Value Coverage
  • Actual Cash Value (ACV) coverage means an insurance company will pay for property damage based on the current cost to repair or replace it, minus any wear and tear.
  • Some insurance policies depreciate labor and other intangible items; this line item can lead to homeowners receiving less money to repair or replace their property.
  • Bulletin 2024-18-INS
  • The new bulletin clarifies that labor to repair covered damage is not a physical object that can depreciate; consumers may be misled by policies that include labor in ACV.
  • Beginning in Jan. 2025, carriers cannot include this language in their standard policy.
  • However, it may be permitted for consumers to include an optional endorsement allowing for depreciated labor in exchange for paying a lower premium.
  • For policies issued or renewed effective Jan. 1, 2025, or after, insurers that wish to depreciate labor or other non-tangible items must do so by a standalone endorsement.
  • Such endorsements must be optional coverage available for a reduced premium.
  • MCH INS will not approve policies that include language that depreciates non-tangible items in the policy definition of Actual Cash Value, Depreciation, etc.

Regulators MCH INS
Entity Types CNSM; Ins
Reference PR, Bul 2024-18-INS, 7/3/2024;
Functions Actuarial and Valuation; Compliance; Financial; Product Administration; Product Design; Reporting; Underwriting
Countries United States of America
Category
State
Products Insurance; Insurance-Property
Regions Am
Rule Type Final
Rule Date 7/3/2024
Effective Date 1/1/2025
Rule Id 218280
Linked to N/A
Reg. Last Update 7/3/2024
Report Section US Insurance

Last substantive update on 07/08/2024